When we consider language loss, we talk about why we should care (and whether we should care it all). When I asked students to think of reasons to care, the more immediate responses seem to relate to knowledge systems: that each language represents something valuable to humanity in terms of knowledge systems encoded in that language, and that that knowledge is of great value to the speech community too.
This comes through in the lovely quote I shared in class from Nick Evans' awesome book Dying Words:
“No-one’s mind will again travel the thought-paths that its ancestral speakers once blazed. No-one will hear its sounds again except from a recording, and no-one can go back to check a translation, or ask a new question about how the language works.For lingusitics students, I think it's also important to share Krauss' well-known quote, that is directed internally at linguists and the field we belong to. It's not something that I think has occurred to students before:
Each language has a different story to tell us. … for certain riddles of humanity, just one language holds the key.” (Evans 2010; xviii)
“We [linguistics] must do some serious rethinking of our priorities, lest linguistics go down in history as the only science that presided obliviously over the disappearance of 90% of the very field to which it is dedicated” (Krauss 1992: 10)But another aspect to why we should care about language loss is a little harder to convey: the personal feelings of loss and even grief that individuals can feel when they do not speak the language of their own heritage. It's really not very typical for us to talk about feelings in a linguistics class, despite their centrality.
Enter Australian singer and musician Mojo Juju. Only a few months ago, she released a song (and great video) called "Native Tongue".
Through her music and lyrics, you get a powerful sense of the personal impacts that not knowing the languages of your heritage (in her case, Wiradjuri and Filipino) can have: difficulties in finding a sense of belonging that others take for granted; anger at that not being understood ("It's easy enough for you to say, it ain't no thing. But I'm the one, you ain't the one, living in this skin"); and the resilience required to stake your place in society. The anger and hurt related to those feelings are also conveyed by her tone and music, not just the lyrics.
It's the first time I've seen issues of language loss represented in popular music. And Mojo Juju has captured it stunningly with a powerful track and video.
|Photograph by Claudia Sangiorgi Dalimore, reproduced |
from The Guardian without permission
Also on this blog in "Sociolinguistic concepts through popular culture"
- Drag queens and how no two speakers are identical
- Mean Girls and social networks
- Bernie Sanders and factors that drive language change
Evans, Nicholas. 2010. Dying words : endangered languages and what they have to tell us. The language library. Chichester, U.K. ; Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell.
Krauss, Michael. 1992. The world’s languages in crisis. Language, 68(1), 4–10.